Take 15% off Cigar Gifts! Use Promo Code: GIFT15 at cart

Middleton Cherry vs. SWRA

Status
Not open for further replies.

ruffinogold

Well-Known Member
Mayor
#21
Try them both, if you don't like them I'm sure our esteemed Mayor ruffinogold will gladly take one and/or both off your hands. :byg:
Yup ... ya can never have to much of either . I think if someone would only try one .. it would be SWRA because of its ease of lighting and keeping lit . MCB isn't hard or anything ,,, it's just not completely brainless
 

dmkerr

PG- free since '83!
Staff member
Moderator
#22
The Cherry blend bit me something terrible, but I don't necessarily blame the tobacco. Probably just a chemical thing 'tween me and it.

SWRA is one of the most impressive aromatics I've ever smoked, even though I didn't care for the flavor. It's so well made that it puts many other aros to shame, OTC or not. I wish I liked it. Again, it's not the fault of the blend... it's my personal tastebuds. Whatever the flavoring is doesn't work for me, but the blend itself is very well done.
 

Smokey Tom

Active Member
Member
#23
The Cherry blend bit me something terrible, but I don't necessarily blame the tobacco. Probably just a chemical thing 'tween me and it.

SWRA is one of the most impressive aromatics I've ever smoked, even though I didn't care for the flavor. It's so well made that it puts many other aros to shame, OTC or not. I wish I liked it. Again, it's not the fault of the blend... it's my personal tastebuds. Whatever the flavoring is doesn't work for me, but the blend itself is very well done.
Very open-minded of you. Especially as you don't like it.
 

dmkerr

PG- free since '83!
Staff member
Moderator
#24
Very open-minded of you. Especially as you don't like it.
SWRA is one I wish I liked. I feel like I'm missing something. If the flavoring was vanilla or chocolate or almost anything except that licquour whatever, I'd be all over it. I wish the companies that shall remain nameless that I used to buy bulk aros from back in my pipeshop days could create an aro that was this well made.
 

#25
Thanks guys! Very helpful replies. I appreciate that :)
I will likely be buying both. If forced to buy only one, it does sound like I would prefer SWRA. But who knows maybe I'll enjoy MCB a great deal.

For what its worth, the prices at the local smoke shop are $3/1.5oz for both MCB and SWRA (as is regular SWR). PA and CH are $4. The bulk tobaccos they have are all $3/oz, and there are some really nice looking non-aros that I'll eventually work my way through.
But right now I'm thinking I need to add a quality, non-vanilla- sopping wet (no offense, just not my cup of tea) aromatic to sweeten up my daily rotation a bit as well as for smoking when non-smoker guests are visiting.
 

#26
Just got back from the smoke shop. They were out of Cherry Blend, expected shipment is tomorrow so I wont have long to wait.
So I bought a pouch of SWRA. He gave me a discount ($2.50 for the 1.5oz pouch!) as he said it had been on the shelf for a while. Just opened the pouch and it smells heavenly :) Good ribbon cut, and looks to be nice and dry the way I like it.
I'll pack up a cob-full shortly and let you know what I think...
 

#27
Smoking the SWRA now in a MM Washington.
I like it a lot. A noticeable fruity flavor, yet the tobacco taste comes through very nicely. Good balance.
The room aroma, according to my brother who is home right now, smells wonderful. The smoke is nice and cool. Definitely no tongue burn or anything. Seems to have a good nicotine content as well.
Very glad I picked this up. Yet another compliment to my daily rotation of straight Burleys, Virginia, and VaBurs.
I definitely recommend this. Thumbs up. :puffy:
 

JimInks

Member
Member
#28
Smoking the SWRA now in a MM Washington.
I like it a lot. A noticeable fruity flavor, yet the tobacco taste comes through very nicely. Good balance.
The room aroma, according to my brother who is home right now, smells wonderful. The smoke is nice and cool. Definitely no tongue burn or anything. Seems to have a good nicotine content as well.
Very glad I picked this up. Yet another compliment to my daily rotation of straight Burleys, Virginia, and VaBurs.
I definitely recommend this. Thumbs up. :puffy:

SWRA is one of the my favorite aros. There's not many tobaccos that I'd smoke all day long, but SWRA would be one of them. If I didn't have so much open stuff now, I'd break down and open a tub. I've three tubs left that I bought in 2007.
 

#29
SWRA is one of the my favorite aros. There's not many tobaccos that I'd smoke all day long, but SWRA would be one of them. If I didn't have so much open stuff now, I'd break down and open a tub. I've three tubs left that I bought in 2007.
Yeah the pouch I got today is an old one according to the proprietor of the shop. This is confirmed by the label on the pouch that does not mention the Lane/Scandinavian company.
Based on my experience with regular SWR, I don't think there would be any drastic changes to the blend (fortunately).

I really haven't aged any tobacco, ever. I did recently pack away some McClelland Red Cake with a "promise" to myself not to smoke it until at least a year.
BTW Jim, Have you noticed if OTC Burley based blends age well? Does their flavor/aroma change much? I could easily stock up on these blends if its worth aging at all. Or just so that I never run out :)
 

#30
SWRA is one of the my favorite aros. There's not many tobaccos that I'd smoke all day long, but SWRA would be one of them. If I didn't have so much open stuff now, I'd break down and open a tub. I've three tubs left that I bought in 2007.
Not to threadjack, but how does SWRA do when aged? I've read on here that aromatics don't age well?

Lane 1Q was one of the first tobaccos I tried. I still have quite a bit of it and do enjoy it occasionally, but it's definitely a lot stronger aromatic than SWRA. I got a pouch of SWRA from the "free samples" thread and have really enjoyed it.
 

JimInks

Member
Member
#31
Having smoked a bit of vintage burleys this year, I've yet to smoke one that has degraded. The 1975 SWR tastes almost exactly like the 2013 version. The 1947 version is a little fuller in taste with the slightest essence of wine, which must have been created in the aging process. The 1947 Edgeworth Ready Rubbed tasted a little deeper in taste compared to the 2008 version, but it's basically the same smoke. I'd buy them to smoke, but burleys generally don't change that much with age. It never hurts to have a cellar, though. :)
 

JimInks

Member
Member
#32
Not to threadjack, but how does SWRA do when aged? I've read on here that aromatics don't age well?

Lane 1Q was one of the first tobaccos I tried. I still have quite a bit of it and do enjoy it occasionally, but it's definitely a lot stronger aromatic than SWRA. I got a pouch of SWRA from the "free samples" thread and have really enjoyed it.
I think SWRA stays the same with age. Later this year, I'll probably pop open one of those tubs I mentioned. and I'll see what 6 years did to it.
 

michiganlover

Active Member
Member
#33
Just got back from the smoke shop. They were out of Cherry Blend, expected shipment is tomorrow so I wont have long to wait.
So I bought a pouch of SWRA. He gave me a discount ($2.50 for the 1.5oz pouch!) as he said it had been on the shelf for a while. Just opened the pouch and it smells heavenly :) Good ribbon cut, and looks to be nice and dry the way I like it.
I'll pack up a cob-full shortly and let you know what I think...
At $2.50 a pouch, I would buy out his entire stock!! Your unlikely to ever see a price that low again. Even the $3 per pouch deal is better than what I pay locally, which is $4 for most pouches.
 

#34
Middleton's Cherry was tied for my favorite (alongside Carter Hall) for a long time. Great smoke, and I never could taste the cherry during the smoke. But the aftertaste reminded me of cherry LifeSavers.

But then I started having allergy problems after smoking it so I stopped. Last year was a real bad year for my allergies though and things have settled down quite a bit. Maybe I'll have to go pick up another pouch sometime soon.

SWRA ... I smoked a pouch a long while back and thought I really liked it. I recently got my sample from Lane (of SWRA) and I'm not sure I like it as much as I thought I did. :puffy:
 

#35
At $2.50 a pouch, I would buy out his entire stock!! Your unlikely to ever see a price that low again. Even the $3 per pouch deal is better than what I pay locally, which is $4 for most pouches.
Yeah I likely will :) This is a very nice and balanced aromatic that I'll always have around from now on. Just finished another bowl. :puffy:
 

#36
Middleton's Cherry was tied for my favorite (alongside Carter Hall) for a long time. Great smoke, and I never could taste the cherry during the smoke. But the aftertaste reminded me of cherry LifeSavers.

But then I started having allergy problems after smoking it so I stopped. Last year was a real bad year for my allergies though and things have settled down quite a bit. Maybe I'll have to go pick up another pouch sometime soon.

SWRA ... I smoked a pouch a long while back and thought I really liked it. I recently got my sample from Lane (of SWRA) and I'm not sure I like it as much as I thought I did. :puffy:
Interesting, I wonder what caused the allergic reaction. Was it like a sore throat?
 

#37
This thread is kickin' in my TAD, I've not tried either of these OTCs. I thought I was going to skip the pipe shop this week, but I guess I'll have to go and get some MC, and SWRA to try. I've never been crazy about flavored tobacco, but I'm gonna try the MC anyway, you guys are a bad influence! :)
Hey there Robin.
If I'm not mistaken you and I seem to have similar tastes in tobacco, so I think you'll probably enjoy SWRA. By far the best aromatic I've smoked, and I normally despise aromatics. As Mayor Ruffinogold said it truly is unique among flavored tobaccos.
 

#39
Don't let the Cherry Blend name fool you into thinking it's a cherry flavored tobacco, it's a very burley forward smoking blend... try it in a cob, you'll see... ;)
You are quite right! I got to smoke a few bowls of MCB this past weekend, and it is really a nice tobacco. I would never have even considered trying it if not for this place! The cherry is just a hint of flavor, and it tastes like it should to me, tobacco, but with a subtle fruit overtone, very nice. I will probably keep a pouch of this around, nice for variety, I like it better than SWR. I have some SWRA, not got to it yet though.
 

#40
You are quite right! I got to smoke a few bowls of MCB this past weekend, and it is really a nice tobacco. I would never have even considered trying it if not for this place! The cherry is just a hint of flavor, and it tastes like it should to me, tobacco, but with a subtle fruit overtone, very nice. I will probably keep a pouch of this around, nice for variety, I like it better than SWR. I have some SWRA, not got to it yet though.
Glad you enjoyed it Robin!
 

Status
Not open for further replies.