Newer Smoker, Ready To Move On To Better Tobacco

Status
Not open for further replies.

JD1969

Member
Member
#1
Hi everyone, I have been smoking a pipe for about a month or so. So far all I have smoked and all I have that is easy to get are the typical drug store brands (Capt. Black, Borkom Riff, etc.). While I enjoy them, I know that there is a huge world out there. I have had a decent amount of cigars and used to smoke the darker, heavy ones. By my reading it looks like I might like a Va or English. What are some winners that I can try without having to risk too much. I know this is probably asked all the time here, so thanks for putting up with my newb questions.
 

Sasquatch

Wizzard
Member
#2
Low risk winners....

McClelland: Jubilee, Frog Morton, British Woods, Virginia Woods

Mac Baren: Navy Flake, Dark Twist, Mixture, HH Vintage Syrian

Robert McConnell: Scottish Cake or Scottish Flake

GL Pease: Maltese Falcon, Odyssey, Westminster (all fairly full flavored)

William P Solomon: Presbyterian Mixture



I always recommend Mac BAren NAvy Flake and McClelland Frog Morton as two "must tries" for anyone who wonders what pipes can be about.
 

Ivycap

Member
Member
#3
You should definitely participate in the Newbie Sampler thread! You'll get to try all kinds of great tobaccos without spending the money you would spend for a bunch of tins. That's how I got on my feet. Here's the link. Check it out!

Newbie Sampler Thread
 

Glenn

Active Member
Member
#4
In my opinion you'll have a hard time going wrong trying McClelland Virginias and G.L. Pease English blends. Get a tin of McClelland Blackwoods Flake, Escudo Navy De Luxe and a tin of GLP Westminster. See what those do for you. Great examples of a virginia, a virginia-perique (vaper) and an english.
 

lastopus

Member
Member
#5
I would recommend something along the lines of Frog Morton as previously mentioned. Another great starter IMO is Shortcut through the mushrooms by just for him tobacconist. PS flakes are light and inexpensive and many of the Boswell blends are very nice. Balkan sasieni is a nice intro to balkan thats not real expensive as well.

It took me a bit to get on well with McClelland's Virginias but they are very good. GLP Robusto and Maltese falcon are very good smokes in the higher end. If your looking for a good nic hit and a strong tobac Petersons Irish flake is yummy too. Presbyterian is a must have in the cellar for me.

Man there are just too many good tobaccos out there!
 

JD1969

Member
Member
#6
Low risk winners....

McClelland: Jubilee, Frog Morton, British Woods, Virginia Woods

Mac Baren: Navy Flake, Dark Twist, Mixture, HH Vintage Syrian

Robert McConnell: Scottish Cake or Scottish Flake

GL Pease: Maltese Falcon, Odyssey, Westminster (all fairly full flavored)

William P Solomon: Presbyterian Mixture



I always recommend Mac BAren NAvy Flake and McClelland Frog Morton as two "must tries" for anyone who wonders what pipes can be about.
Thank you for the Frog Morton suggestion. I just finished a small bowl and it is really good. I am not certain how to describe the flavor other than I really like it :blink:
 

woodbutcher

Member
Member
#7
Frog Morton is good, isn't it? I just wish I could get the wife to agree.
If you like it...try some Blend 5110 from McClellans. I can't tell the difference and it's sold at "bulk" prices.
Happy smoking.
Dan
 
#8
Peter Stokkebye PS-701 Virginia Long Cut -- Lots of B&Ms carry this in bulk, and it is a good, mild Virginia. Basic, with no frills.

Peterson Old Dublin -- Fairly common for B&M is this english sold by the tin. I'd say it's a solid notch below Squadron Leader. A good, dependable smoke.

Samuel Gawith Squadron leader -- Carried by many B&Ms but chronicly out of stock, because people buy it up fast. This is the quintessential English that others are compared to. Rarely bested.
 

Marine Dad

Member
Member
#9
JD1969 received this sampler today that I sent him last week. Maybe he can find a few that he likes ! :D

Club Blend
Full Virginia Flake
Blackwoods Flake
Opening Night
CountrySide
Tudor Castle Arcade
Sunday Picnic
Long Golden Flake
St. James Woods
Scottish Mixture
Premium Burley
Prince Albert Choice
 

Marc

Active Member
#10
Yepper! It's time to move up to Big Boy tobaccos like McClelland #5100, #2010, Christmas Cheer (any year), McCranies Red Ribbon or Red Flake or any of the McClelland Premium aromatics.
 

JD1969

Member
Member
#11
I cannot thank you enough Greg. I have no idea where to start on this, but I do have a whole day off to myself on Wednesday and nothing really to do......until now. I am looking forward to the Boswell Premium Burley, the smell in the bag is really good.
Thanks again
JD
 

Rugbysh9

Active Member
Member
#12
JD1969 received this sampler today that I sent him last week. Maybe he can find a few that he likes ! ;)

Club Blend
Full Virginia Flake
Blackwoods Flake
Opening Night
CountrySide
Tudor Castle Arcade
Sunday Picnic
Long Golden Flake
St. James Woods
Scottish Mixture
Premium Burley
Prince Albert Choice


:D Nice bomb MD...


JD we're all going to be eagerly awaiting your tasting comments :bing:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.